From the BBC:
“Northern Ireland Troubles: Controversy Legacy Bill passes
through Commons”
The government's controversial Legacy Bill has passed after a
vote in Westminster, despite widespread opposition in Northern Ireland. A bid
by the House of Lords to amend the bill was voted down by 288 to 205. The bill
ends new Troubles-era cases and inquests and offers conditional amnesty to
those accused of killings. The Irish government is considering legal action
against the UK over the bill which the Democratic Unionist Party said was
"abhorrent". The bill will return to the Lords next week before going
for royal assent. It has been widely opposed by victims groups and all of
Northern Ireland's political parties. The government has said the legislation,
which applies to all former members of the security forces and
ex-paramilitaries, is an attempt to draw a line under the events of the past. Prosecutions
that are currently ongoing will continue to conclusion.
Veterans groups - such as the Northern Ireland Veterans
Movement - widely support the bill. However, some other military veterans have
criticised it. On Tuesday, the Lords backed an amendment to give victims'
families a greater say in granting immunity from prosecution to offenders. But
the Conservative majority in the House of Commons rejected that on Wednesday,
clearing the path for the legislation to be sent for royal assent.
Northern Ireland Secretary Chris Heaton-Harris told the House
of Commons it was incumbent on the government to find a process that "can
deliver positive outcomes for as many of those directly affected by the
Troubles as possible". "We must be honest about what we can
realistically deliver for people in circumstances where the prospects of
achieving justice in the traditional sense are so vanishingly small," he
added.
What has the reaction been?
Taoiseach (Irish prime minster) Leo Varadkar said it was
"the wrong way to go about dealing with legacy issues in Northern
Ireland". "There aren't many things that all of the five main parties
in Northern Ireland agree on but they all agreed this is wrong, and this is not
victim-centred and not human-rights proofed," Mr Varadkar told reporters
in County Wicklow. He said the Irish attorney general is preparing advice on
whether the case could be taken to the European Court of Human Rights,
"essentially saying that this bill, this act is not compliant with the
European Convention on Human Rights, of which United Kingdom is a
signatory".
'Exceptionally cruel'
(John Finucane)
DUP assembly member Emma Little-Pengelly said the
"abhorrent" passage of the bill represents a "dark day for
innocent victims of the Troubles". Ms Little-Pengelly said the bill
"plays into the hands of those who want to airbrush the past". SDLP
leader Colum Eastwood said he was "angry and ashamed" at the outcome
of the vote and called on the Irish government to intervene. "The British
Government doesn't care about the rights of victims but the international human
rights standards that we all enjoy must be defended," he said.
Speaking before the debate, Sinn Féin MP John Finucane
described the bill as devastating for families, adding it would unilaterally
close the door on them getting truth and justice. Mr Finucane's father,
solicitor Pat Finucane, was shot dead by loyalist gunmen at his home in Belfast
in 1989. "When we had the New Decade, New Approach political agreement,
the British government made a promise, a commitment, in that agreement that
they would legislate for Stormont House within 100 days," he said. "One
hundred days later, they made a very public and dramatic U-turn without any
consultation. "The British government have refused to listen and refused
to act, and instead they plough ahead with a piece of legislation which is
exceptionally cruel."
People Before Profit assembly member Gerry Carroll said
communities "must rally in opposition" to the bill. "Truth and
justice are rights that have never truly been afforded to victims here,"
he said. "Campaigners have vowed not to give up in their pursuit of
justice and will not stop opposing this rotten legislation."
How do victims' families feel?
(Billy McGreanery's uncle, William McGreanery, was killed by
the Army on 15 September 1971)
Grainne Teggart, of Amnesty International UK, said it was a
"dark day for justice" and that the law only absolves "those
responsible for conflict-related abuses - and, shamefully, all under the guise
of reconciliation". Victims' rights campaigner Raymond McCord, whose son
Raymond Jnr was murdered by loyalists in 1997, said the UK government had shown
no compassion for victims. "My next step is taking the government to
court, [they] simply don't care about truth and justice," he said. Kenny
Donaldson, from victims' organisation South East Fermanagh Foundation (SEFF),
said the government had "effectively relinquished their responsibilities
in overseeing justice". "It is regrettable that they were not willing
to accept the very reasonable amendment which came from the House of Lords
yesterday which would have ensured that victims and survivors could feel
somewhat empowered."
The family of a man who was shot and killed by a soldier in
Londonderry on 15 September 1971 earlier labelled the legacy bill "a
disgrace". William McGreanery was shot in the Bogside area of Derry by a
member of the 1st Battalion Grenadier Guards. His nephew, Billy McGreanery, who
was just 13 when his uncle was killed, said he feared the bill could rob many
families of justice. Their own family's case is currently with the Public
Prosecution Service (PPS). "I think a terrible injustice has been done to
every family in this country," Mr McGreanery told BBC Radio Foyle. "On
the worldwide stage it's a disgrace that they are treating people this way and
if this was any other part of the UK, I don't think they would get away with
this."
The topic of dealing with the past has been a contentious
political issue for a long time in Northern Ireland. More than 1,000 killings
from the Troubles have never been solved. It has been brought into the main
news headlines in recent years as a soldier has been in court charged with
murdering two people in 1972. The man, known only as Soldier F, is accused of
killing the men during what became known as Bloody Sunday, when the Army's
Parachute Regiment opened fire on a civil rights march in Derry.
^ This is wrong on every level and should NOT pass! ^
No comments:
Post a Comment
Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.