Monday, May 5, 2014

Deny Denial

From MT:
"Putin Outlaws Denial of Nazi Crimes"

President Vladimir Putin signed a law on Monday making the denial of Nazi crimes and distortion of the Soviet Union's role in the World War II a criminal offense punishable by up to five years in jail. The law, described by critics as an attempt to curb freedom of expression to appease conservative Russians, the ex-KGB spy's main support base, also criminalizes the public desecration of war memorials. The Kremlin has used World War II as a pillar to unite a society that Putin has said lost its moral bearings following the 1991 Soviet collapse. It has become increasingly risky for Russians to dispute an official line that glorifies the wartime achievements of the Soviet leadership and plays down its errors. The new law would ban "wittingly spreading false information about the activity of the U.S.S.R. during the years of World War II." Russian officials and media have raised the specter of Nazi Germany repeatedly during Moscow's confrontation with the West over Ukraine, calling the overthrow of a Russian-allied president in February a coup carried out in part by "neo-Nazi" forces. Independent channel Dozhd was taken off the air earlier this year after asking viewers whether Leningrad, now St. Petersburg, should have been given to German troops to save lives during its 872-day siege during World War II. Viktor Shenderovich, a blogger critical of the authorities, came under fire from Kremlin supporters in February after comparing the Sochi Olympics to the 1936 Berlin Olympic Games, used by Adolf Hitler to burnish the image of the Nazi Germany. In a comment posted when the legislation was first introduced, veteran television host Vladimir Pozner said he believed its aim was "to shut the mouths of journalists, historians and writers". He said he feared it would "practically ban criticism of Stalin" for "grave mistakes that led to the deaths of hundreds of thousands of our soldiers". It was unclear whether the wording of the bill had been changed since its introduction and Pozner could not immediately be reached for comment. Kremlin critics say Putin, in power since 2000, has used legislation, court cases and other levers to tighten control during his current term, which he won despite large opposition protests in 2011-2012. Putin denies the accusations. Separately on Monday, Putin signed a law imposing fines for the use of expletives on television, radio and in films shown in theaters. Music and movies containing foul language will have to have a warning on the label, state-run RIA news agency reported. Putin also signed a law imposing stricter rules on bloggers, which opponents say is aimed at suppressing criticism on the Internet.

^ I completely agree with making it illegal to deny the crimes the Nazis did (not just in Russia, but all over the world.) I do have an issue with the other part of the bill about criticizing what the Soviet Union did during the war. The history that Russians 20 and over learned is not the complete history. It is the glorified Communist history. They didn't learn about the NKVD killing at Katyn, the Soviet occupations of Poland, Latvia, Lithuania, Estonia or Bessarabia, the raping of civilians by Soviet soldiers or that Jews were the main targets of the Nazis in places like Auschwitz and Babi Yar. I remember talking to Russians who got so mad when the topic of World War 2 came up and you questioned anything bad. Most didn't even know that Stalin and Hitler were trading parties from 1939-1941 or that the USSR only declared war on Japan a few days before the end of the war and that was only to get northern Korea and the Kuril Islands (technically Japan and Russia are still at war as they never made a peace agreement.) There were many horrible things and stupid choices that all sides made during the war (and in any war.) If you deny people to seek the truth (rather than simply "tow" the official, whitewashed party-line) then you are only hurting your own history. A country has it's good and it's bad and that includes the things in its past. The true sign of a great country is one that can acknowledge the bad with the good and learn from it. ^

   http://www.themoscowtimes.com/news/article/putin-outlaws-denial-of-nazi-crimes/499526.html

No comments:

Post a Comment

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.