What If's

From the BBC:
"#BBCtrending: Should Russia have surrendered Leningrad?"

Is it ok to question how events unfolded during World War Two? That's a hot topic of discussion on social media in Russia right now. This week is the 70th anniversary of the end of the siege of Leningrad during WW2, and on Sunday the independent Russian TV station Dozhd conducted what turned out to be a very controversial poll. They asked whether Leningrad - now St Petersburg - should have been handed over to the Nazis in order to save lives. Hundreds of thousands of Russians died in Leningrad during the blockade - which lasted more than two years - but was a key turning point in the war. Asking this simple question led to a social media storm against Dozhd TV. Thousands were outraged - arguing that even posing this question was an insult to the dead. The Soviet Union's victory in World War Two remains a source of great national pride and by Monday, a hashtag which translates as "brown rain" (#коричневыйдождь) was trending - the "brown" referring to the colour of Nazi uniforms, and the "rain" to the name of the station (which translates as Rain TV).  Dozhd apologised and deleted the post, but the criticism was fierce. On Twitter, they were called "idiots" with no grasp of history, and less than human. Many politicians condemned the poll, including MP Irina Yarovaya from the ruling United Russia party, who called it an attempt to "rehabilitate Nazism". The city parliament in St Petersburg on Wednesday called for a ban on the station. Staff at the Vesti news website were sacked for posting this image of Joseph Goebbels on Facebook - it has now been removed But others defended Dozhd. "There's nothing more frightening than a ban on analysing the past," was one of the supportive tweets. Others questioned whether the furore online was orchestrated to give the authorities an excuse to crackdown on the station - Dozhd is seen as a liberal alternative to pro-Kremlin media.  But soon, angry users were targeting state media too. This happened after someone scanning the state-run Vesti news website's Facebook page found an image of Nazi propaganda minister Joseph Goebbels. It was part of a picture gallery of "great people" and their comments on Lenin. It's unclear who posted the picture or why, but Vesti promptly sacked its entire social media marketing team.

^ The Leningrad Blockade was a horrible episode in both World War 2 and Soviet/Russian history. With that said, I do not see any problem with merely posing "what if" questions to people. It doesn't diminish what the soldiers and civilians went through in Leningrad/Saint Petersburg. It seems that there is more to this story than meets the eye. It looks like there is a political motive behind going after the station and newspaper. Putting Goebbels alongside "great people" is just as bad as putting Lenin or Stalin and yet the latter two are easily seen as great Russians (despite the fact that Stalin was actually Georgian.) Russia doesn't really like to look too deep into their own past and answer the majority of questions and this seems to go along those lines of not wanting to hear anything bad. ^

http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/blogs-trending-25945781