Early Withdrawal?

From the BBC:

"Trump sees total rout of Islamic State group as imminent"

US President Donald Trump has said territory held by the Islamic State group in Syria and Iraq could be "100%" liberated as early as next week. "It should be announced, probably some time next week, that we will have 100% of the caliphate," he told a gathering of coalition partners. However, he also cautioned that he wanted to "wait for the official word". US military and intelligence officials say IS could stage a comeback without sustained counter-terrorism pressure. Mr Trump shocked coalition allies in December when he declared that the group had been defeated, amid reports he wanted to pull out US soldiers within 30 days. But he later slowed the withdrawal after several resignations from key defence officials and strong criticism from Republicans and allies abroad. The global coalition against IS, now numbering nearly 80 nations, was formed in 2014 after the group overran swathes of territory and went on to launch terror attacks outside the region.  "Their land is gone," he told Wednesday's conference in Washington. "The Isis [IS] caliphate has been decimated." But the group still had "tiny sections that can be so dangerous", he said, and "foreign fighters must not gain access" to the US.  He also referred to the IS propaganda machine, which recruited fighters from Europe and other regions "For a period of time they used the internet better than we did," he said. "They used the internet brilliantly but now it's not so brilliant." The US leader thanked coalition partners, saying, "We will be working together for many years to come." Secretary of State Mike Pompeo pledged the US would continue to fight IS, despite withdrawing troops from Syria. He called the troop pullout a "tactical change... not a change in the mission", and said the world was entering an "era of decentralised jihad".  It has certainly lost control of most of the territory it overran, including its strongholds of Mosul in Iraq and Raqqa in Syria.  However, fighting continues in north-eastern Syria, where the Kurdish-led Syrian Democratic Forces (SDF) say they captured dozens of foreign fighters in recent weeks. On Tuesday the head of the US military's Central Command, Gen Joseph Votel, told a Senate committee up to 1,500 IS militants remained in a 20 sq mile (52 sq km) pocket on Syria's border with Iraq.  The group, he said, still had "leaders, fighters, facilitators, resources and the profane ideology that fuels their efforts". Meanwhile, a report by a US defence department watchdog cited Central Command as saying that without sustained pressure IS "could likely resurge in Syria within six to 12 months". Another challenge is what to do with the hundreds of foreign fighters captured by the SDF, as well as their families. Governments in their home countries are reluctant to take back radicalised militants who swore allegiance to Islamic State.  President Trump's comments were more than a month late, as he did not consult his allies about his decision in December to withdraw US troops from Syria. The shock from the surprise announcement has settled, but coalition members want to know how this is going to play out. It's not clear that the administration has sorted that out.  Both Mr Trump and Mike Pompeo called on other nations to take on more commitments for the continued campaign against the IS group, but said they were still in the fight - America would continue to lead it, Mr Pompeo said.  Mr Trump had previously suggested that some of the troops in Syria could be moved to American bases in neighbouring Iraq, from where they could launch commando operations across the border as necessary.  But there are still no official details about how the US will continue the counter-terrorism pressure Mr Trump's generals and intelligence officials have said is necessary to stop IS militants from staging a comeback.

^ It is not good or smart to prematurely make statements that say an enemy has been defeated and you are withdrawing from the fight when the enemy hasn't been defeated. Bush made that mistake on the aircraft carrier when he said "mission accomplished." That haunted his political legacy ever since. Obama made an even worse mistake when he withdrew all American forces from Iraq prematurely and ISIS was then allowed to come in and wreak havoc around the world. That has haunted his political legacy ever since. If Trump does the same in Syria (or Afghanistan) then that will not only affect his political legacy but also endanger people - including Americans - around the world. ^

https://www.bbc.com/news/world-us-canada-47149088